top of page

Navigating Frivolous Criminal Proceedings: A Legal Guide to Addressing Malicious Summoning Orders

Writer's picture: Devesh SaxenaDevesh Saxena

Updated: Jan 21


Navigating Frivolous Criminal Proceedings: A Legal Guide to Addressing Malicious Summoning Orders

In recent years, an increasing number of individuals have found themselves embroiled in frivolous and irregular criminal proceedings initiated with malicious intent. Often, such cases are designed to harass the accused, tarnish their reputation, and misuse the judicial process. If you find yourself facing such allegations, it is crucial to understand the legal remedies available to safeguard your rights and seek justice. Below, we discuss a recent judgment from the Hon'ble Allahabad High Court and provide a roadmap for addressing such challenges.


Case Background: A Malicious Criminal Proceedings and Summoning Order:


The matter at hand involved an accused person, who faced criminal proceedings based on an FIR lodged on September 24, 2022. The complaint alleged offenses under Sections 323, 504, 506, and 354 of the Indian Penal Code (IPC) following a trivial parking dispute in an apartment complex in Gautam Budh Nagar. The FIR alleged physical assault and abusive behavior, but subsequent investigations revealed significant discrepancies and contradictions:

  • Contradictory Statements: The complainant’s statements under Sections 161 and 164 CrPC contained material contradictions.

  • Independent Witness Accounts: Statements of independent witnesses confirmed no physical or sexual violence occurred.

  • CCTV Evidence: Footage corroborated the absence of any assault.

  • Investigation Findings: The investigating officer excluded Section 354 IPC from the chargesheet, underscoring the lack of evidence for sexual harassment.


Despite these facts, the Chief Judicial Magistrate issued a summoning order on April 15, 2024, prompting the applicant to approach the Hon'ble Allahabad High Court under Section 482 CrPC seeking the quashing of the entire proceedings pending in the learned Court below, as well as the quashing of the impugned charge sheet and summoning order.


High Court Intervention:


The Allahabad High Court stayed the lower court proceedings in its order dated January 7, 2025. The court acknowledged the lack of substantial evidence, noting that the FIR and subsequent charges appeared to be motivated by mala fide intentions to harass the applicant. This decision reinforces the judiciary’s commitment to preventing abuse of the legal system.


Legal Principles Established:


The High Court’s order reflects key principles derived from landmark judgments:

  1. Quashing of Frivolous Cases: The Supreme Court in Indian Oil Corporation v. NEPC India Ltd. (2006) 6 SCC 736 emphasized that proceedings initiated with malice or ulterior motives should be quashed.

  2. Protection Against Civil Disputes Being Criminalized: In Deepak Gaba v. State of Uttar Pradesh (2023 SCC OnLine SC 3), the Court highlighted that vexatious criminal cases camouflaging civil disputes must be dismissed at the threshold.

  3. Assessment of Prima Facie Evidence: Courts must carefully scrutinize the evidence to determine whether a prima facie case exists.


Steps to Address Malicious Proceedings:


If you are faced with frivolous criminal charges or a perverse summoning order, consider the following steps:

  1. Analyze the FIR and Evidence: Examine inconsistencies, contradictions, and lack of corroboration in the allegations and evidence.

  2. Seek Quashing Under Section 482 CrPC: File an application in the High Court to quash the FIR or summoning order. Highlight abuse of process and absence of prima facie evidence.

  3. Obtain Interim Relief: Request a stay on further proceedings to prevent coercive action during the pendency of your case.

  4. Present Strong Documentation: Submit independent witness statements, CCTV footage, and any other evidence that counters the allegations.

  5. Engage Legal Counsel: Consult an experienced advocate to ensure proper representation and effective argumentation in court.


Conclusion:


Frivolous criminal proceedings not only waste judicial resources but also cause undue mental and financial stress to the accused. By understanding your rights and leveraging the legal remedies available, you can protect your interests and uphold the sanctity of justice.


If you or someone you know is facing similar challenges, reach out to S&D Legal Associates for expert legal guidance. Our team is dedicated to ensuring justice prevails against all odds.


 

Read Order:


 

The matter before Hon'ble Allahabad High Court was argued by Adv. Devesh Saxena (Partner, S&D Legal Associates) and the petition was drafted by Adv. Utkarsh Shubham (Associate, S&D Legal Associates).


54 views

Comments


DISCLAIMER: The information contained in this website is provided for informational purposes only, and should not be construed as legal advice on any matter. The transmission and receipt of information contained on this Web site, in whole or in part, or communication with any partner or associate of S&D Legal Associate via the Internet or e-mail through this website does not constitute or create a lawyer-client relationship between us and any recipient. The material on this website may not reflect the most current legal developments. The content and interpretation of the law addressed herein is subject to revision. We disclaim all liability in respect to actions taken or not taken based on any or all the contents of this site to the fullest extent permitted by law. Do not act or refrain from acting upon this information without seeking professional legal counsel.

©2020 by S&D Legal Associates.

bottom of page